GST WEEKLY UPDATE :33/2026-27 (15.11.2026) By CA Vipul Khandhar

0
Spread the love
Reading Time: 12 minutes

-By CA Vipul Khandhar

  1. CBIC Consultation on Alternate Mechanism for Liability & ITC Amendment in GST Returns:

Key Consultation Snapshot

  • Issuing Authority: Central Board of Indirect Taxes & Customs (CBIC), Ministry of Finance (pursuant to 57th GST Council Meeting recommendations dated 08.10.2026).
  • Consultation Window: November 01, 2026 to November 30, 2026 on MyGov (submissions per area are non-editable once submitted).
  • Proposed Effective Date: April 2027 Return Period.
  • Core Objective: Eliminate manual editing in FORM GSTR-3B by mandating source-level corrections through GSTR-1/1A/IFF (for liability) and IMS/Electronic Ledgers (for ITC), thereby rendering mismatch intimation rules (Rules 88C and 88D) redundant.
  1. Summary of Proposed Amendments to GST Forms & Rules
Form / Rule Core Objective & Statutory Backing Key Proposed Changes & Structural Additions Operational Impact on Taxpayers
FORM GSTR-1

 

(Rule 59(1))

Granular tagging of outward supplies and reconciliation of E-Commerce Operator (ECO) transactions. • Table 4 (B2B): Split to carve out ECO-TCS supplies (new 4E) and SEZ non-authorised operations (4F).

• Tables 5, 7 & 10 (B2C): Split to segregate ECO-TCS supplies from regular B2C supplies.

• Table 6 (Zero-rated): New drop-down (Col 4A) for Goods/Services; shipping bills updateable via Table 9.

• Tables 8AA & 12A (New): Enables amendments to prior-period Exempt/Nil-rated supplies and HSN summaries.
• Tables 9 & 11 (CDNs & Advances): New drop-down tagging notes/advances to original supply tables.

• Tables 14 & 15 (ECO): Recipient-type and tax-period tagging in 14(a) for GSTR-8 matching; SEZ authorised/non-authorised split added in Table 15.

Prevents credit/debit notes and advances from auto-populating into the wrong GSTR-3B tables; enables exact supplier-ECO reconciliation; allows voluntary invoice-linking for CDNs.
FORM GSTR-1A

 

(Proviso to Rule 59(1))

Pre-GSTR-3B rectification window for both current and prior tax periods. • Expanded Scope: Allows adding/amending details of earlier tax periods (subject to Sec 37(3) time limit), including IFF details.

• GSTIN Correction: Restriction on amending recipient GSTIN removed.

• Structural Mirroring: Aligned with all new sub-tables of GSTR-1.

Eliminates the need to manually alter GSTR-3B for last-minute errors; updates flow into the recipient’s next open GSTR-2B; remains optional with zero late fee.
FORM GSTR-2B & IMS

 

(New Rule 60(6A), Rules 60(7)–(9))

Statutory backing for Invoice Management System (IMS) and dynamic ITC computation. • Mandatory Action: Recipients must Accept, Reject, or keep Pending supplier docs (no action = deemed accepted). Bills of Entry cannot be rejected.

• Pending Timelines: Invoices/DNs up to Sec 16(4)/(6) limit; Credit Notes (CNs) capped at 2nd succeeding month (monthly) or next quarter (quarterly).

• GSTR-2B Restructuring: Maps ineligible ISD credits/CNs directly to Table 4 (auto-populating 3B Table 4(D)(2)); adds Table 6 for rejected docs.

• Dynamic Revision: Revised GSTR-2B can be regenerated on request post-14th before filing GSTR-3B.

Keeping a CN pending attracts Sec 50(3) interest if original ITC was already utilized. Rejected CNs automatically increase the supplier’s liability in their next return (New Rule 67B).
FORM GSTR-3B

 

(New Rules 61(1A), 61(1B))

Transformation into a locked, reconciled summary return. • Liability Lock: Outward liability strictly locked to GSTR-1/1A/IFF; prior-period errors fixed only via subsequent outward statements.

• ITC Lock: Non-RCM ITC locked to GSTR-2B; GSTR-3B cannot be filed until GSTR-2B is generated.

• New Table 4(AA): Dedicated row for reclaiming ITC previously reversed under 4(B)(2), replacing the confusing dual-entry in 4(A)(5) and 4(D)(1).

Ends manual overrides in GSTR-3B; streamlines ITC reclaim reporting; auto-populates ineligible ISD credit in 4(D)(2) without requiring manual reversal in 4(B)(1).
FORM GST PMT-02A

 

(New Rule 86C)

Statutory Electronic Credit Reversal and Reclaim Statement. • Tracks opening balance, temporary reversals made in 3B Table 4(B)(2), PMT-10 rectifications, and reclaims claimed in Table 4(AA). System-enforced cap: ITC reclaimed in Table 4(AA) cannot exceed the available balance in PMT-02A.
FORM GST PMT-02B

 

(New Rule 86D)

Statutory Electronic Statement of RCM Tax Paid & ITC Claimed. • Tracks RCM tax paid in 3B Table 3.1(d) against RCM ITC claimed in Tables 4(A)(2) (import of services) and 4(A)(3) (domestic RCM). System-enforced cap: RCM ITC claimed cannot exceed current-period RCM tax paid plus available PMT-02B balance.
FORM GST PMT-04

 

(Amended Rules 85, 86, 87)

Unified discrepancy reporting mechanism. • Expanded to include checkboxes for discrepancies in PMT-02A and PMT-02B, routed to the jurisdictional proper officer. Provides formal statutory recourse to resolve portal ledger balance mismatches in reclaim and RCM statements.
FORM GST PMT-10

 

(New Rule 61(1B))

Self-assessment rectification of excess permanent ITC reversals. • New application to correct excess permanent reversals made in GSTR-3B Table 4(B)(1) (e.g., under Sec 17(5), Rules 38, 42, 43) within Sec 39(9) limits. Solves a major operational pain point: excess permanent reversals are credited back to the Electronic Credit Ledger (or PMT-02A if reclaimable).
FORM GST DRC-03

 

(Rules 142(2) & (3))

Preventing double taxation on voluntary post-audit/scrutiny payments. • Split into Part A (payment) and Part B (new Tables 7A & 7B for B2B invoices/debit notes), to be filed within 7 days of Part A. Part B auto-populates GSTR-1 (non-editable) so the recipient gets ITC in GSTR-2B, while ensuring the tax is not added again to the supplier’s GSTR-3B liability.
  1. Operational Matrix: Draft Circular on ITC Reporting & Error Rectification (Annexure C)
Scenario / Error Type Prescribed Action under Proposed Mechanism Interim Action (Until Portal Utilities Go Live)
Sec 16(2) conditions unmet (e.g., goods/invoice not yet received) Keep document Pending on IMS instead of accepting and reversing in 4(B)(2). Same (IMS pending functionality is active).
Credit Note on rejected invoice / zero-ITC invoice Accept the CN on IMS and use the portal facility to declare zero/actual ITC reduction (do not reject). Same.
Inadvertent Rejection on IMS Request supplier to re-report the document in the GSTR-1 amendment table, then Accept it. Same.
Inadvertent Acceptance on IMS Request supplier to amend the document in GSTR-1A or subsequent GSTR-1, then Accept the amendment. Same.
Excess Reversal in Table 4(B)(2) (Temporary) Reclaim the excess amount in Table 4(AA) in a subsequent return. Reclaim via Tables 4(A)(5) and 4(D)(1).
Wrongly reported in 4(B)(2) instead of 4(B)(1) Reverse permanently in Table 4(B)(1) and simultaneously reclaim in Table 4(AA) in a subsequent return. Reverse in 4(B)(1) and reclaim via 4(A)(5) + 4(D)(1).
Excess Reversal in Table 4(B)(1) (Permanent) File self-assessment application in FORM GST PMT-10 (within Sec 39(9) time limit). Reduce the following period’s Table 4(B)(1) reversal by the excess amount.
Wrongly reported in 4(B)(1) instead of 4(B)(2) File FORM GST PMT-10 to restore balance to PMT-02A, then reclaim via Table 4(AA) when eligible. Reduce following period’s 4(B)(1) reversal and report under 4(B)(2).
Short Reversal in GSTR-3B Reverse the shortfall in a subsequent GSTR-3B along with applicable interest under Sec 50(3). Same.
  1. Key Consequential CGST Rule Changes
  • New Rule 67B (Supplier Liability on Rejected Credit Notes): Where a recipient rejects a credit note (or upward CN amendment) on IMS, the corresponding tax is automatically added to the supplier’s liability in their next GSTR-3B/GSTR-5, carrying interest from the original due date of the return period in which the CN was declared.
  • Omission of Rules 88C and 88D: System-generated intimations for GSTR-1 vs. GSTR-3B liability differences (DRC-01B) and GSTR-2B vs. GSTR-3B ITC differences (DRC-01C) are proposed to be omitted prospectively from April 2027, as system-level locks prevent such discrepancies at the filing stage.

 

  1. Maharashtra State Tax Department Overhauls GST Audit Selection for FY 2023–24: Shift from Risk-Based to Risk-Assessment-Based Framework: Reference: Instructions No. CST/ACST/HQR-05/GST-Audit/2023-24/Guidelines/B. 85, dated October 30, 2026:Issuing Authority: Office of the Commissioner of State Tax, Maharashtra:

Executive Summary

The Office of the Commissioner of State Tax, Maharashtra, has instituted a comprehensive overhaul of its Goods and Services Tax (GST) audit selection methodology for Financial Year 2023–24. Issued with the approval of the Commissioner of State Tax, Instructions No. CST/ACST/HQR-05/GST-Audit/2023-24/Guidelines/B. 85 transition the department’s Section 65 audit selection protocol from an automated risk-based selection model to a structured, evidence-backed risk-assessment-based selection framework.

Background and Policy Rationale

The new framework builds upon the two-tier selection architecture—comprising centralised data analytics and field-level intelligence under the Local Importance category—previously established through Internal Circulars 09A of 2023 (22.12.2023), 04A of 2024 (24.05.2024), 10A of 2024 (29.11.2024), and 7A of 2025 (03.11.2025).

An internal departmental evaluation of audit proceedings conducted for FY 2022–23 identified systemic operational bottlenecks that diluted audit efficiency and quality, including:

  • Superficial Preparatory Work: Inadequate desk reviews and audit plans drafted without requisite analytical diligence.
  • Procedural Drift: Loss of focus on core identified issues during ongoing proceedings, accompanied by routine, unfocused requisitions of voluminous taxpayer records lacking nexus to specific risk parameters.
  • Improper Delegation: Shifting primary verification burdens onto taxpayers rather than conducting departmental analysis.
  • Low-Value Case Selection: Recommending Local Importance cases based on minor GSTR-1/GSTR-3B mismatches involving revenue below ₹5 lakh.
  • Administrative Delays: Late commencement of audits resulting in last-minute Audit Monitoring Committee escalations and insufficient supervisory oversight by Deputy Commissioners heading Audit Units.

Core Pillars of the Revised Audit Framework

1. Pool-Based Allocation and Mandatory Desk Review

Centrally flagged cases will no longer be directly assigned to individual audit desks for automatic initiation. Instead, a curated pool of cases exhibiting verifiable risk indicators will be allotted to each Audit Division. Before recommending any case for formal audit, Audit Units must execute a thorough desk review synthesizing:

  • Sectoral trends and historical audit outcomes;
  • Intelligence inputs from the Economic Intelligence Unit (EIU);
  • Analytics from BIFA, the E-Way Bill MIS portal, and supply chain mapping; and
  • Past show cause notices and credible open-source intelligence.

2. High-Value Revenue Risk Thresholds

To ensure audit bandwidth targets substantive revenue leakage, cases may be recommended for Section 65 audit only where quantified revenue risk exceeds:

  • ₹2 Crore in the Mumbai Metropolitan Region (MMR) and Pune Metropolitan Region (PMR); and
  • ₹1 Crore in the rest of Maharashtra.

Crucially, this threshold must stem from non-routine parameters distinct from standard return-scrutiny discrepancies (enumerated in Annexure-A). Routine mismatches may only be tagged as supplementary issues, while unaddressed risks in cases not selected for audit are to be routed to the jurisdictional proper officer for return scrutiny under Section 61.

3. Centralised Gatekeeping via PRAISE

Proposals must be routed by the Joint Commissioner (Audit) through the PRAISE platform in the prescribed format (Annexure-B), mirroring enforcement selection protocols. A Central Selection Committee, convening twice weekly (every Tuesday and Friday), will scrutinize submissions and approve only those proposals that articulate specific audit issues and substantiate revenue risk with concrete analytical backing.

4. Cross-Zone Allocation and Sectoral Balance

  • Criss-Cross Allocation: In MMR and PMR, initial case pools are distributed across Zones on a criss-cross basis (Annexure-C), insulating case evaluation from local familiarity and enhancing objectivity.
  • Sectoral Proportionality: Pools specify sector-wise case distributions alongside proportionate recommendation targets to prevent disproportionate targeting of isolated industries.

5. Supervisory Accountability and Targeted Requisitions

  • Deputy Commissioner Ownership: Only the concerned Deputy Commissioner is permitted to present audit proposals before the Central Selection Committee.
  • Focused ADT-01 Notices: Every proposal must include a draft FORM GST ADT-01 requesting strictly those books and records directly tied to the identified risk areas. Approved issues must be mandatorily embedded into the formal audit plan.

6. Capped Field Visits

To curb unwarranted physical visits to taxpayer premises, the Zonal Additional Commissioner is empowered to authorize field audit visits in up to 30% of total selected cases within a Zone. Any visit exceeding this ceiling requires prior sanction from the Central Selection Committee.

Implementation Roadmap: First Lot of Cases

Parameter Operational Directive
Initial Pool Size 3,258 cases distributed across Audit Divisions/Units based on risk parameters and audit objectives specified in Annexure-D.
Desk Review Timeline 15 days from the issuance of the Instructions (October 30, 2026) to complete desk reviews and submit recommendations.
Target Conversion Rate Each Audit Division is expected to recommend approximately 10% of its allotted pool based on desk-review merit.

Key Takeaways for Taxpayers and Practitioners

  • End of Fishing Expeditions: The mandate to attach a targeted draft FORM GST ADT-01 at the approval stage directly addresses industry grievances over sweeping, boilerplate record requisitions. Taxpayers receiving ADT-01 notices for FY 2023–24 should verify that requisitioned records align with identifiable risk areas.
  • Elevated Thresholds Mean Deeper Scrutiny: Because cases crossing the ₹1 crore / ₹2 crore threshold undergo rigorous pre-audit validation by the Central Selection Committee, taxpayers selected for Section 65 audit should expect highly focused, data-backed inquiries rather than routine return-reconciliation checks.
  • Jurisdictional Spillover for Routine Mismatches: Taxpayers with GSTR-1/3B or ITC discrepancies falling below the new audit thresholds should anticipate targeted scrutiny notices from jurisdictional officers rather than full-scale audit proceedings.
  1. ICAI Releases Updated GST Handbook on Liability of Directors, Partners, Business Transferees, and Legal Heirs (Sections 85–94 of CGST Act):

Scope and Legal Principles

While Goods and Services Tax (GST) liability ordinarily rests with the supplier under the forward charge mechanism or the recipient under the reverse charge mechanism, Chapter XVI of the CGST Act extends recovery and payment liability to third parties and representatives under specific statutory circumstances.

The Handbook clarifies that such secondary or vicarious liability is not automatic merely due to a person’s association with a business. Instead, it is triggered strictly upon the fulfillment of statutory conditions, adherence to principles of natural justice, and proper adjudication and recovery procedures.

Summary of Statutory Provisions (Sections 85–94)

Section Subject Matter Key Statutory Principles & Coverage
Section 85 Transfer of Business Joint and several liability of transferor and transferee for tax, interest, and penalty payable up to the date of transfer (whether determined before or after transfer).
Section 86 Agent and Principal Joint and several liability for GST on taxable goods supplied or received by an agent on behalf of a principal; distinguishes an “agent” from an “intermediary.”
Section 87 Amalgamation or Merger Addresses GST implications on inter-company transactions during the intervening period and defines statutory liabilities of amalgamating/amalgamated entities.
Section 88 Company Liquidation Outlines duties of liquidators, mandatory intimation timelines, and personal liability of directors for unrecovered dues if non-recovery stems from gross neglect or breach of duty.
Section 89 Directors of Private Companies Establishes joint and several liability of directors for unpaid tax, interest, or penalty, subject to the statutory defense of proving absence of gross neglect, misfeasance, or breach of duty.
Section 90 Partners of Firms Covers joint and several liability of partners for firm dues, including notice requirements and timelines governing the liability of retiring partners.
Sections 91 & 92 Guardians, Trustees & Receivers Governs representative liability where business is conducted on behalf of minors, incapacitated persons, or estates managed by trustees, Court of Wards, or receivers.
Section 93 Special Cases (Death/Succession) Defines liability of legal representatives or successors continuing or discontinuing a business upon the death of a taxable person.
Section 94 Other Cases (Dissolution/Partition) Addresses tax recovery following discontinuance, dissolution, or partition of firms, Hindu Undivided Families (HUFs), and Associations of Persons (AOPs).

Key Clarifications and Judicial References

  • Post-Transfer Determination & Going Concern Distinction: Under Section 85, a transferee can be held liable even if the tax demand is determined after the transfer date, provided it pertains to the pre-transfer period. The Handbook draws a clear legal distinction between the transfer of individual business assets and the transfer of a business as a going concern. In this context, it references key judicial rulings—including M/s JR Metal Chennai Ltd. v. Assistant Commissioner of Central Tax (Andhra Pradesh High Court, 2024)—alongside Notification No. 12/2017-Central Tax (Rate) (dated June 28, 2017) exempting the transfer of a going concern, and Circular No. 96/15/2019-GST (dated March 28, 2019) governing business continuity following the death of a sole proprietor.
  • Procedural Safeguards: The publication underscores that tax authorities cannot bypass mandatory notice, tax determination, and adjudication protocols before initiating recovery against directors, partners, legal heirs, or transferees.
  1. Important Judgements:

          (i) Cross-Head Adjustment of Excess IGST Against CGST/SGST Liability Held to Be a Condonable Procedural Lapse: GSTAT Bengaluru

          (Commissioner of Central GST, Bengaluru v. M G Automobiles Sales and Services [Appeal No. APL/43/BUR/2026, decided on October 08, 2026]:Forum: Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT), Bengaluru Bench)

Executive Summary

The Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT), Bengaluru Bench, has ruled that where a taxpayer erroneously discharges excess Integrated Goods and Services Tax (IGST) on credit notes and subsequently adjusts that excess against its Central GST (CGST) and State GST (SGST) liabilities instead of claiming a formal refund, the irregularity constitutes a mere procedural lapse. Dismissing the Revenue’s appeal, the Tribunal affirmed that a bona fide, revenue-neutral error—particularly during the nascent stages of GST implementation—cannot be used to fasten a fresh tax demand alongside interest and penalty.

Factual Background

  1. Erroneous Tax Payment: During the first year of GST implementation, M G Automobiles Sales and Services (“the Respondent”) inadvertently paid excess output IGST on certain credit notes.
  2. Self-Adjustment Across Tax Heads: Rather than filing a statutory refund application under Section 54 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 (“CGST Act”) to reclaim the excess IGST and separately discharging its CGST and SGST liabilities in cash or through eligible Input Tax Credit (ITC), the Respondent adjusted the excess IGST paid against its outward CGST and SGST liabilities.
  3. Adjudication and First Appeal: The Adjudicating Authority confirmed a demand for CGST and SGST, accompanied by interest and penalty, on the premise that cross-head adjustment of tax liabilities is impermissible under the GST framework. On appeal, the First Appellate Authority set aside the demand, prompting the Revenue to prefer an appeal before the GSTAT.

Issue for Consideration

Whether the unilateral adjustment of excess IGST paid against CGST and SGST liabilities—bypassing the prescribed refund mechanism—justifies raising a fresh demand for CGST and SGST along with interest and penalty, even where the transaction is bona fide and revenue-neutral.

Key Holdings and Ratio Decidendi

Dismissing the Revenue’s appeal and upholding the order of the First Appellate Authority, the GSTAT Bengaluru Bench laid down the following principles:

  • Procedural Irregularity vs. Substantive Evasion: While the statutory architecture of GST separates tax heads (IGST, CGST, and SGST) and prescribes a specific refund route for excess tax paid, deviating from this procedure by adjusting excess IGST against CGST/SGST liabilities amounts to a procedural lapse rather than tax evasion.
  • Bona Fide Conduct in the Transitional Period: The Tribunal took judicial notice of the complexities and teething troubles faced by taxpayers during the initial year of GST rollout. Where the taxpayer’s conduct is transparent and devoid of mala fide intent, technical infractions should not be penalized disproportionately.
  • Principle of Revenue Neutrality: Because the excess IGST was already deposited into the government exchequer, the subsequent adjustment against CGST and SGST did not result in any actual loss of revenue to the State or Centre as a whole. Confirming a fresh demand under CGST and SGST while retaining the excess IGST would amount to unjust enrichment by the exchequer and double taxation on the same underlying transaction.

Practical Implications for Taxpayers and Practitioners

Dimension Takeaway for GST Compliance & Litigation
Audit & Scrutiny Defense Taxpayers facing departmental notices for cross-head adjustments or erroneous reporting in GSTR-3B (especially for FY 2017–18 and early transitional periods) can rely on this precedent to argue revenue neutrality and absence of intent to evade tax.
Substantive Justice Reinforces the settled tax jurisprudence that substantive benefits cannot be denied, nor fresh demands sustained, solely on account of venial or procedural breaches where the exchequer has already received the tax due.
Recommended Practice Despite the relief granted in litigation, taxpayers should continue to follow the statutory route (claiming a refund of excess tax paid or utilizing formal DRC-03/fund-transfer mechanisms where applicable) to avoid protracted departmental disputes.

Disclaimer:

This publication contains information for general guidance only. It is not intended to address the circumstances of any particular individual or entity. Although the best of endeavour has been made to provide the provisions in a simpler and accurate form, there is no substitute to detailed research with regard to the specific situation of a particular individual or entity. We do not accept any responsibility for loss incurred by any person for acting or refraining to act as a result of any matter in this publication.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

error: Content is protected !!